top of page

A Comparative Analysis of Submittal Planning Software for Metal Roofs: AutoCAD, Revit, and Tekla Structures

Introduction

Submittal plans play a crucial role in the successful execution of metal roof projects, ensuring accurate design representation and streamlined communication among stakeholders. Among the various software options available, AutoCAD, Revit, and Tekla Structures stand out as popular choices. This article aims to compare and contrast these three software solutions in the context of creating submittal plans for metal roofs.


AutoCAD

AutoCAD is a versatile and widely used computer-aided design (CAD) software known for its flexibility in 2D drafting and 3D modeling. When it comes to metal roof submittal plans, AutoCAD provides a robust platform for creating detailed drawings with precision. Its extensive library of tools allows designers to create intricate metal roof designs, including components like panels, flashing, and fasteners. However, AutoCAD might be considered more traditional compared to newer software options.


A Screen Gab of Autodesk AutoCAD LT 2024
A Screen Gab of Autodesk AutoCAD LT 2024

Revit

Revit, developed by Autodesk, is a Building Information Modeling (BIM) software that offers a collaborative platform for architectural, structural, and MEP design. Unlike AutoCAD, Revit focuses on parametric modeling, enabling users to create intelligent 3D models. In the context of metal roof submittal plans, Revit excels in providing a holistic view of the entire building structure, allowing for more accurate clash detection and coordination. It fosters collaboration among different disciplines involved in the project.

Tekla Structures

Tekla Structures is renowned for its advanced capabilities in structural design and detailing, making it a popular choice for metal roof submittal plans, especially in the context of large and complex structures. Tekla's emphasis on structural detailing and fabrication ensures that metal roof plans are not only accurate but also optimized for construction. It stands out in handling steel and metal components, offering specialized tools for detailing connections, bolts, and welds.


Comparison

1. Modeling Approach:

- AutoCAD: Primarily 2D and 3D drafting.

- Revit: Parametric 3D modeling with a focus on BIM.

- Tekla Structures: Advanced 3D modeling with a specialization in structural detailing.

2. Collaboration and Coordination:

- AutoCAD: Limited collaboration features compared to BIM platforms.

- Revit: Strong collaboration capabilities, promoting interdisciplinary coordination.

- Tekla Structures: Excellent coordination for steel and metal structures, ensuring accuracy in submittal plans.

3. Detailing and Fabrication:

- AutoCAD: Comprehensive detailing but may require additional plugins for specialized tasks.

- Revit: Detailed modeling with an emphasis on architectural and MEP components.

- Tekla Structures: Specialized in structural detailing, offering advanced tools for metal components.

Conclusion

Choosing the right software for metal roof submittal plans depends on project requirements and priorities. AutoCAD remains a reliable choice for 2D and 3D drafting, while Revit excels in collaborative BIM environments. Tekla Structures, with its focus on structural detailing, is ideal for projects with intricate metal structures. Ultimately, the decision should align with the specific needs of the project and the preferences of the design and construction teams.

10 views0 comments
bottom of page